
Marriott Jacksonville Downtown
Best for travelers who want city-centre access to Jacksonville theaters, museums, sports venues, and a full-service hotel with on-site dining and a rooftop pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Marriott Jacksonville Downtown is a 4-star riverfront hotel in Jacksonville with a rooftop pool, on-site dining, and event space; read this if you want downtown access, meetings or a city-base for exploring Northeast Florida. 2958 S Fletcher Ave is a 3-star, 3-bedroom cottage in Fernandina Beach on Amelia Island for beach-focused vacation stays and self-catering groups — read this if you want a home-style beach address near Amelia Island sights.
Updated · about 36 miles apart

Best for travelers who want city-centre access to Jacksonville theaters, museums, sports venues, and a full-service hotel with on-site dining and a rooftop pool.

Best for families or small groups wanting a private 3‑bed house near Fernandina Beach and Amelia Island attractions with basic in-unit conveniences and free Wi‑Fi.
When Marriott Jacksonville Downtown wins: choose Marriott for downtown convenience, a rooftop pool with skyline and river views, two on-site dining bars/restaurants, a full events program, and hotel services (24-hour front desk, concierge, valet parking).
When 2958 S Fletcher Ave wins: pick the cottage for a quieter, beach-area stay on Amelia Island with a full kitchen, three bedrooms, and a neighborhood location near Fernandina Beach parks and golf courses — ideal for self-catered vacations or small groups.
Bottom line: Marriott Jacksonville Downtown is the better choice for travelers who need hotel services, dining and meeting space in downtown Jacksonville; 2958 S Fletcher Ave is the simpler, lower‑service beach cottage option for people who prioritize proximity to Fernandina Beach and a private house layout.
| Category | Marriott Jacksonville Downtown | 2958 S Fletcher Ave |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | 4-star full-service downtown hotel with event space and on-site restaurants/bars | 3-star private cottage / holiday house for self-catered stays |
| Location | 245 Water St, downtown Jacksonville on the St. Johns River near performing arts venues | 2958 South Fletcher Avenue, Fernandina Beach on Amelia Island, near Seaside Park and local beaches |
| Size | 354 guest rooms; multiple meeting rooms and ballrooms | House (3 Bedrooms) — single rental unit |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 | All ages welcome; not adults-only |
| Pools | One outdoor rooftop pool (river/skyline views) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Juliette's Bistro (modern American/Southern) and J Bar (cocktails, small plates) | Self-cater kitchen; no on-site signature restaurants listed |
| Spa & wellness | Complimentary fitness center; spa status not confirmed | Not published |
| Known for | Downtown riverfront location, rooftop pool, event/wedding facilities | Coastal Amelia Island address close to Fernandina Beach, Seaside Park and local golf |
| Wi‑Fi & connectivity | In-room Wi‑Fi; complimentary for Bonvoy members booking direct | Free WiFi (listing) |
Marriott Jacksonville Downtown sits on Water Street along the St. Johns River, within walking distance of arts venues and downtown attractions.
Choose Marriott for central riverfront access to Jacksonville's cultural and event hubs.
2958 South Fletcher Avenue is a 3-bedroom cottage on Amelia Island in Fernandina Beach, positioned for beach and island activities.
Choose 2958 S Fletcher Ave for easy access to Fernandina Beach and Amelia Island outdoor activities.
Marriott offers a range of guest rooms and accessible options across a large downtown hotel inventory.
Marriott suits guests who want hotel amenities, multiple room types, and accessible room options.
2958 S Fletcher Ave is listed as a single House (3 Bedrooms) rental with a full kitchen and living area.
The cottage is best for travelers who want a private home layout and a kitchen for self-catering.
Marriott has two on-site venues for meals and drinks.
Marriott is the clear choice if you prefer on-site restaurants and evening bar options.
2958 S Fletcher Ave is a self-contained cottage with a kitchen rather than hotel dining venues.
Pick the cottage if you prefer cooking in or eating out at local restaurants rather than hotel dining.
Marriott features one rooftop outdoor pool with river and skyline views.
Marriott provides hotel pool access with city and river views; good for guests who want a pool in the city.
The supplier listing for 2958 S Fletcher Ave does not publish an on-site pool or direct beachfront amenity.
2958 is a beach‑area cottage but its listing does not confirm an on-site pool or private beachfront — expect a short drive to public beaches.
Marriott provides onsite fitness and an active downtown nightlife nearby.
Marriott suits guests who want hotel fitness facilities and immediate access to downtown nightlife and performance venues.
2958 is a rental house suited to quieter evenings or local dining and beach-based activities.
Choose the cottage if you want a low-key evening near beaches and local restaurants rather than hotel nightlife.

Marriott Jacksonville Downtown — large event spaces and ballrooms, plus on-site catering and meeting rooms.

2958 S Fletcher Ave — a 3-bedroom house near Fernandina Beach for groups who want a private home on Amelia Island.

Marriott Jacksonville Downtown — Juliette's Bistro and J Bar provide full-service dining and bar options on site.

2958 S Fletcher Ave — full kitchen, living space and a private 3‑bedroom layout for families or groups.
2958 S Fletcher Ave is closer to Fernandina Beach and Amelia Island beach parks; Marriott requires a 20–30 minute drive to Jacksonville-area beaches.
Marriott Jacksonville Downtown has Juliette's Bistro and J Bar on site; 2958 S Fletcher Ave provides a kitchen for self-catering and nearby local restaurants.
Yes. Marriott welcomes guests of all ages (with a 21-year minimum check-in age), and 2958 S Fletcher Ave is not adults-only.
The supplier listing for 2958 S Fletcher Ave does not publish an on-site pool; the listing emphasizes proximity to local beaches and parks.
Explore how Marriott Jacksonville Downtown stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·